Fractional flow, the flow that shapes our future.

Posts Tagged ‘The Red Queen


In this post I present a closer look at 4 developed discoveries (of a total of 10) that started to flow as from 2012 and their production as of September 2013 as these have been reported by the Norwegian Petroleum Directorate (NPD).

A common feature for several of the recent developments offshore Norway is that they have estimated recoverable reserves ranging from 10 – 100 Million Barrels of Oil Equivalents (MBOE) and are expensive to develop and generally developed with sub sea completed wells flowing back to an existing (host) installation for processing. The host installation normally provides for essential services for the operations of these sub sea installations. These discoveries typically annual flow are 15 – 25% of estimated recoverable reserves at some kind of plateau and enter into steep declines as they become 50 – 60% depleted. Normally these developments reach expected plateau a few months after they start to flow.

Several of the recent smaller developments* on the Norwegian Continental Shelf (NCS) have so far under-performed with regard to expected production. So far these have resulted that some companies have taken some write downs, and others will have to accept considerably lower returns on their investments.

The presented 4 developments were now expected to flow a total of 90 – 100,000 BOE/d. Actual data from NPD show that these 4 developments had an average total flow of 13,000 BOE/d for August and September 2013.

*) By smaller developments are here meant discoveries with estimated recoverable reserves  below 100 Million Barrels Oil Equivalents (MBOE).

This is worrisome for several reasons:

  • Write downs and lowered returns impact the companies’ financial abilities to develop future capacities and to carry through planned exploration activities.
  • Write downs destroy shareholder value.
  • If there is a general trend with weakened profitability and/or losses from smaller developed discoveries (which for some time has been dominant on NCS), this may lead to future revisions of the criteria the companies use for commercialization of these. In other words more experiences confirming the uncertainties surrounding smaller discoveries could push the commercial break even price lower, thus deferring developments of such discoveries that already are within the companies’ portfolios.
    This may fly under the radar coverage with the euphemism “targeting financial performance”.
  • To finance these developments, the companies took advantage of their debt carrying capacities and took on more debt. The companies thus bet their future on households and sovereigns (already overstretching their debt carrying capacities) being able to continue to take on more debt to pay for more expensive oil and natural gas so that the companies can retire their debts as these mature.
  • Apart from price, production flows have a considerable impact on companies cash flows and profitability. In the short to mid term it is more about the flows and less about the stocks.
  • The developments of these smaller discoveries have so far reduced the decline in total production from the legacy installations on the NCS as can be seen in figure 1. For some time these smaller developments also hid the “The Red Queen” effect from NCS discoveries brought to flow since 2002, refer also figure 2.
  • A more reserved attitude of the companies towards future developments of the discoveries made (and to be made) due to financial considerations, sets up the potential for a near term further acceleration of the decline in total NCS crude oil production.

This also illustrates that future developments now appear to be at the crossroads with what price the oil companies need for development of discoveries with what the consumers will continue to afford.

Figure 1: Development in crude oil production from the Norwegian Continental Shelf (NCS), split on fields flowing prior to January 1st 2002 (green) and discoveries developed to flow as from 2002.

Figure 1: Development in crude oil production from the Norwegian Continental Shelf (NCS), split on fields flowing prior to January 1st 2002 (green) and discoveries developed to flow as from 2002.

The new developments have now reduced the annualized total decline in crude oil production from NCS to just above 7%, refer also to figure 2. Discoveries/fields flowing prior to 2002 has seen a decline in their total crude oil production of more than 70% since 2002.

Read the rest of this entry »


I denne andre delen om utvinning av olje fra skifer i Bakken formasjonen i Nord Dakota vil jeg presentere resultatene fra de statistiske analysene av brønnene som ble studert. Videre lønnsomhetsvurderinger for ”gjennomsnittsbrønnen” slik historiske utvinningsdata fra North Dakota Industrial Commission definerte denne.

Figur 01: Figuren ovenfor er hentet fra ”Through the Looking-Glass” av den engelske forfatteren Charles Lutwidge Dodgson (kanskje bedre kjent under sitt psevdonym Lewis Carrol) som var forfatter, matematiker og logiker.
At the top of the hill, the Red Queen begins to run, faster and faster. Alice runs after the Red Queen, but is further perplexed to find that neither one seems to be moving. When they stop running, they are in exactly the same place. Alice remarks on this, to which the Red Queen responds: “Now, here, you see, it takes all the running you can do to keep in the same place”.

Etter presentasjoner og diskusjoner av resultatene fra studien synes nå en passende metafor for den videre utviklingen i skiferutvinning å være godt representert ved ”The Red Queen” (fra eventyret ”Through the Looking-Glass”) som hele tiden måtte løpe fortere og fortere for å kunne stå stille.

Dette for å beskrive hvorfor teknologi og/eller pris ikke kan overvinne det uunngåelige faktumet at funnstørrelser og brønnproduktivitet faller i de fleste basseng enten dette gjelder skifer eller andre petroleumsbasseng.

Sagt på en annen måte; utvinning av olje og gass fra skifer får ingen dispensasjoner fra de fysiske lovene eller historikken for områdeutvikling.

Første del av presentasjonen av studien er her.

Read the rest of this entry »

Written by Rune Likvern

Saturday, 8 September, 2012 at 16:23

%d bloggers like this: